What Apple Could Learn from Microsoft: Front Row Versus Windows Media Center

While the iMac G5's software interface forsorts on your PC, and lets you burn them to CD
multimedia - Front Row - is new to the Macor DVD with a couple of clicks. But it also gives
platform. Windows users have had similar tools -you access to tons of online content, including
in Microsoft's Windows XP Media Center Edition -movies from CinemaNow ( pre-recorded television
for a couple of years now. Is it possible that, asshows from Akimbo.com, and news broadcasts
Front Row matures, it could learn a thing or twofrom Reuters and other services. One huge
from Windows?irritation with Media Center is that clicking on some
Feel the musicbuttons calls up ads for paid content.
For music, Front Row gives you a large, text onlyBut when it comes to television, Media Center's
interface with few options. You can shuffle thebiggest advantage over Apple's offerings is that
playback order of songs and search by severalyou can connect a Media Center PC to a TV,
criteria. You can't create playlists, but you canoften through high quality component connections.
access playlists you've already created in iTunes.Media Center plays, pauses, and records television
And you can't browse internet radio stations, butprogrammes; if the PC has a TV-tuner card with
you can access stations you've bookmarked intwo tuners, it simultaneously record two
iTunes.programmes and play back a third.
Media Center gives you those same navigationalYou can add an external TV tuner and digital
and playback tools, and then goes a couple ofvideo recorder, such as Elgato Systems' EyeTV,
steps further. It shows album artwork and alsoto the iMac G5, but Front Row won't have
provides a search engine that will show results asanything to do with it.
you enter characters on the remote control.Currently, you can view over-the-air
Some Media Center PCs have over-the-air radioHigh-Definition (HD) broadcasts only with Media
tuners, but the software will also let you accessCenter, and then only if the PC's TV and supports
internet radio stations.HD. Microsoft recently announced that Media
You can't browse or buy new songs throughCenter PCs with CableCard support will appear by
Front Row; for that, you must use iTunes. MediaChristmas; those systems should be able to play,
Center displays a prominent 'Buy Music' buttonpause, and record HDTV programmes, without
once you start playback, but clicking on it calls upthe need for a set-top cable box.
a page of albums and a 'Not designed for MediaA Media Center PC particularly outdoes the iMac in
Center' message. In other words, it doesn't workone area: it can't act as a server, distributing
any better than Front Row.content (including time-shifted television) to other
DVDs on the menudevices throughout the house. Those devices
Because the iMac G5's remote has only sixinclude Media Center Extenders and the new
buttons, the fast-forward and fast-rewind buttonsXbox 360, which has built-in wireless networking.
must do double duty as chapter advancingPlaying catch-up
buttons. And you can't adjust the volume untilWhen it comes to controlling a multimedia
after you begin playback. DVD playback is prettycomputer, OS X isn't anywhere near Windows XP
simple, but you will find out that the wrongMedia Center Edition. But Media Center has been
buttons are often pressed.around for more than three years; comparing the
The remote control supplied with Media Centerfledgling Front Row to it is about as fair as
PCs has dedicated buttons for nearly every DVDcomparing a bicycle to a BMW. And Apple's
function, so it is easy to look at the remote andsuccess with digital audio players - which weren't
pick exactly what you want to do. The interfacenew when it began selling them - shows that the
is quite snappy, so you'll always get confirmationcompany can enter a product category and outdo
that button presses has registered.the competition by offering better features and
Straight to videomore style.
Front Row gives you easy access to movie filesClearly, Mac users are not going to be buying
and video podcasts stored on your iMac, and toMedia Center-equipped PCs anytime soon (and the
movie trailers stored on Apple's servers. You cansame is true for Windows users and iMacs). But if
play back TV shows, too, but you have to useFront Row picks up some of the extra features
iTunes to find and purchase them. Everythingthat Media Center has acquired over the years,
playbacks in full-screen window, which makes thethose users may soon have reason to be very,
320 240 pixel TV shows look pretty fuzzy.very happy.
Media Center lets you play back videos of all